The Main Cup, a Middletown, Maryland restaurant staple known far and wide across the tri-state region for its unique charm and quality dining experience, has announced a change in ownership.
The Brenengen Family, the founders and long-time operators of the Middletown destination, revealed in a Facebook post on Monday, March 4, 2024, that the establishment was sold to Frederick’s Hootch & Banter proprietors.
In a heartfelt announcement on Facebook, the Brenengen Family shared, “It is with gratitude and excitement that we announce an important transition in the life of The Main Cup.”
“Our journey has been one of growth, passion, and community… the Main Cup has been more than just a restaurant – it has been a gathering place, a hub of friendship, and a second home for many,” The Brenengen Family said.
Established in 2007, The Main Cup has become a cornerstone of Middletown’s historic downtown and has served as a beloved gathering place, offering an inviting atmosphere, high-quality, freshly-made American cuisine, and a commitment to excellent service.
Cherished for its warm atmosphere, The Main Cup’s commitment to freshly made, high-quality American cuisine, and unwavering dedication to excellent service.
The Main Cup is a cornerstone of the Middletown community, offering a unique blend of an inviting atmosphere, high-quality, freshly-made American cuisine, and a commitment to excellent service.
Its roots trace back over a century to when it was originally Main’s Ice Cream and Butcher Shop, a detail that adds to its charm and historical significance in the area.
As they prepare to hand over the reins to the owners of Hootch and Banter, the family shared their confidence in the new proprietors, saying: “We couldn’t have imagined better entrepreneurs, individuals, and human beings to take the reins of this beloved establishment.”
They emphasized that the new owners’ “passion for hospitality and commitment to community align perfectly with the values that have defined the Main Cup since its inception.”
This Hootch & Banter team brings a fresh perspective to The Main Cup, backed by a successful track record that includes the culinary creativity of Executive Chef Ricky Ade and the mixology expertise of Head Bartender Jeff Naylor.
With his rich background in various esteemed restaurants and a passion for quality and creativity, Chef Ade joined Hootch & Banter in December 2022.
His culinary philosophy centers on freshness and innovation, promising an exciting future for The Main Cup’s menu.
Meanwhile, Jeff Naylor, a Frederick native and a fixture on Market Street, has earned acclaim for his ability to reimagine classic cocktails with personal flair, suggesting potential new directions for The Main Cup’s beverage program.
The Brenengen Family describes the sale as a decision rooted in gratitude and excitement for the future.
“We couldn’t have imagined better entrepreneurs, individuals, and human beings to take the reins of this beloved establishment,” they expressed in their announcement, highlighting the alignment of values between the two parties.
The transition is a testament to the restaurant’s enduring legacy and role as a gathering place for friends and family in Middletown.
As The Main Cup turns the page to this next chapter, the focus remains on celebrating its history while embracing the opportunities that come with new ownership.
This change signals a promising new era for the Middletown hotstop, with the Hootch & Banter team poised to infuse the establishment with their signature blend of culinary excellence and innovative hospitality.
As Middletown residents and visitors await the unveiling of The Main Cup’s next evolution, the spirit of camaraderie, quality dining, and community engagement that has defined the restaurant since its inception is poised to continue, if not flourish further, in the years to come.
Inviting the community to embrace this new chapter, the Brenengen Family urged, “We invite you to join us in celebrating the legacy of the Main Cup and welcoming the new owners with open arms.”
“Thank you for the many years of success, service, and connection. We look forward to seeing you at the Main Cup one last time and raising a toast to new beginnings.”